Last Seen Alive

October 15, 2021
Boston police detective Ellery Hathaway finally steels herself to confront the sociopath who abducted, tortured, and nearly murdered her as a teenager. The reunion doesn't go as planned. Kate Hunter, host of TV's true-crime show On the Hunt, thinks a great way to mark the 20th anniversary of self-styled artist Francis Michael Coben's conviction and imprisonment would be to interview him on camera, and she insists on inviting Ellery, who was snatched from his clutches years ago by FBI Agent Reed Markham, to the party as well. Ellery reacts to this coldhearted proposal first with denial, then with dread, but ultimately agrees for several reasons. In return for his hour on prime time, Coben's agreed to give information about the fate of Tracy Trajan, one of his 16 victims who didn't get rescued, who's been missing since 1998--a revelation Ellery thinks could help Tracy's parents achieve closure. In addition, she can't help being interested in the chance to put Coben in his place by showing that now he's the helpless one, not her. Mainly, though, she wants to help Reed get evidence that could connect the recent murder of Maxine Frazier, a sex worker killed by a copycat who shares Coben's unhealthy fixation with severed hands, to Coben's own crimes. Nothing all that terrible happens during the interview, but shortly after, an E. coli outbreak in the Indiana prison where Coben is serving time sends him to the hospital, and you can just guess what happens next. When you invoke Hannibal Lecter this pointedly, you deserve to know: Francis Coben is no Hannibal Lecter.

COPYRIGHT(2021) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Starred review from November 1, 2021
For two decades, many people have viewed Ellery Hathaway only as the sole survivor of serial murderer/kidnapper Francis Coben, as revealed in Schaffhausen’s excellent fifth installment of this superior series (after 2021’s Every Waking Hour). Ellery’s rescue at age 14 by FBI agent Reed Markham has affected all aspects of her life, from home security measures to her career as a Boston police detective. To try to free herself from her past, she recently ended her relationship with Reed that began the year before. Now, Coben, responsible for the mutilation deaths of at least 17 young women, has a deal—he’ll confess where he buried eight other women if Ellery visits him in prison. Ellery agrees, but the meeting has some surprising consequences. The author highlights Ellery’s emotional state and the grief of the families desperate to know what happened to their loved ones as the suspenseful plot builds to a stunning finale. The chilling Coben, who shows that pure evil can lurk behind a handsome face, makes a memorable villain. Readers will be eager to see what happens next. Agent: Jill Marsal, Marsal Lyon Literary.

December 10, 2021

The fifth in the series featuring Ellery Hathaway (following Every Waking Hour) reunites FBI Special Agent Reed Markham and Boston police detective Hathaway. Serial killer Francis Coben, in prison awaiting execution, promises to reveal details of unsolved murders he is suspected of in exchange for an exclusive interview that includes the only victim that got away--Hathaway. Markham and Hathaway both refuse, until they discover a name on Coben's list of victims that was new, murdered only months ago, long after Coben was locked up. Desperate to find Coben's connection to the new killer and provide answers for the families of the missing women whom Coben is suspected of killing, Hathaway agrees. The past comes screaming back to haunt them as Hathaway and Markham search for a new killer and find themselves hunted again by another looking to settle an old score. VERDICT What starts as a basic police procedural becomes much more as the plot twists and turns, leaving readers uncertain about whom to root for right up to the end. Will appeal to fans of Meg Gardiner, Bryan Gruley, and Brian Freeman.--George Lichman, Rocky River, OH

Copyright 2021 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

January 1, 2022
Boston detective Ellery Hathaway and Special Agent Reed Markham, introduced in The Vanishing Season (2017), return for a foreshadowed showdown with serial killer Francis Coben. The trio has a dark history: as a rookie cop, Reed rescued teenage Ellery from Coben's torture room. Now, Ellery is a cop struggling to reconcile her feelings for Reed and her notoriety as Coben's ""final girl."" Coben reels Ellery and Reed back into his net with a promise to reveal the locations of previously unknown victims to celebrity crime reporter Kate Hunter, if she can snag Ellery's participation in the television production. Coben has provided a list of names, but one of them doesn't fit, as Ellery's BPD partner investigated Maxine Frazier's disappearance after Coben was apprehended. Is Coben hinting at a new copycat disciple? Whatever the game, Reed and Ellery's loyalty to Coben's victims demands that they play. An immensely satisfying resolution to the pair's unresolved issues with Coben and each other. The novel's complex plotting and explosive climax benefit from Schaffhausen's television-production experience.

COPYRIGHT(2022) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

June 1, 2022

Ellery Hathaway is a Boston police officer, who at age 14, was abducted by serial killer Francis Coben and was rescued by rookie FBI agent Reed Markham. Twenty years later a popular reporter wants to interview both Hathaway and Coben for a new TV program, which brings the FBI and agent Markham into the picture. Coben coerces Ellery to agree to participate, and later, with help from outside the prison, orchestrates his transfer from death row to a hospital. He escapes and resumes his killing spree. Without enlisting the aid of the FBI, Ellery lures Coben to her, only to be re-abducted. He is surprised to find that Hathaway is no longer a frightened teen, but rather a trained police officer. The story seems somewhat formulaic but gets the blood pumping and it is well read in alternating chapters by narrators Seth Podowitz and Danielle Gensler. VERDICT This fifth "Ellery Hathaway" mystery continues the story of the complex main characters well known to series fans. Newcomers might feel the lack of background from previous series installments.--Joanna M. Burkhardt

Copyright 2022 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.